Friday, January 6, 2012

Did we punish the wrong man and party in 2004?????























2011 was undoubtedly the year when we spoke and agitated most about a single issue that is ‘corruption’. The finale to this debate was the speech by Shri Shivanand Tiwari of Janta Dal (united) followed by the unacceptable conduct of Congress in Rajya Sabha. 
 
The larger issue at stake is the future of this country. India has been adrift politically and economically right through this year, government neither displayed the will nor the ability to tackle and rectify the situation.

We are extremely unfortunate we do not have a Prime Minister who could rise to the occasion, take hold and say he is in charge, comparisons between the incumbent and his predecessors is a natural corollary under such circumstance.
“Seven years of talking down the economy, bullying and pressurising private enterprise, discounting India’s innate entrepreneurship and replacing it with a culture of profligate, top-down populism, and refusing to deregulate and liberalise sectors crying out for change have left the country feeling miserable. The set of factors that caused the 2002-2009 boom is exhausted. The NDA sowed, the UPA reaped. What has the UPA sowed?”  Link

“After the Lok Pal Bill fiasco in the Rajya Sabha, the cynicism about the Congress will grow. Frankly, the party broke all norms of propriety by not allowing the vote. You cannot govern when your credibility is low. I think the Congress has convinced itself that in the electoral arithmetic, all it needs to do is to show that it is marginally better than the BJP, but that is still not good enough for the country.”  Link

Between 1998 - 2002, NDA added 27,00,000 jobs in Small scale industry alone. That's more than what Sonia & MMS added across ALL industries in 7 yrs!

Few know that 2002 was the worst drought in India in 21st century. The way Vajpayee & Advani handled it made it seem like a regular year!

Vajpayee's BJP govt started the world's largest food security program Antyodaya Anna Yojana. Rice Rs2/kg & wheat Rs.3/kg for 10 cr people!

It was the BJP govt of Vajpayee, that setup Rs.1Crore award for DRDO scientists and technicians. Congress neglected them for 50 years.

During the 6 years of NDA rule in India, 161 ISI modules in various parts of the country were busted. That was impressive. #Security

Congress & rest sanctioned 2.3cr phone lines over the first 50 years. BJP govt sanctioned 4.75 cr lines in just ONE term. #TelecomRevolution.

When Vajpayee took over as PM, Phone STD rates were Rs.24 per minute. When he stepped down, it was Rs.5 per min. Incredible work done.

During 5 decades of mostly Congress rule, 6 lakh villages in India had a measly 36 lakh phones in total. BJP govt tripled it in just 1 term.

The length of optical fibre, key for IT revolution, was only 0.65 lakh km in 1999. BJP govt increased the length by a whopping 650% in 4 yrs!

Few people know that India's hardware exports registered a whopping 192% increase during just 1 term of Vajpayee govt. Employment generator.

ITES (enabled services) was almost non-existent in India in 1998.By 2004 it had Rs.15,750 cr turnover and employed 2,20,000 youngsters! #BJP

Sher Shah Suri died in 1545. It took an Atal Bihari Vajpayee, 454 years later, to start India's next big road construction project. 2-Jan-99

During 50yrs of Congress rule, India built 556 KM of 4/6 lane highways, at 11 KM per YEAR. Vajpayee/Advani built 25,000 KM at 11 KM per DAY!

Just the Golden Quadrilateral that Vajpayee govt built would save Rs.8000 crore of fuel consumption in India, EACH year. Massive oil saving.

he 60,000cr Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojna that BJP govt launched in 2000,was the largest rural infrastructure program in India's history!

Congress guys might not tell you.. 1,86,000 villages in India had NO road connectivity after 50+yrs of dynasty rule. Vajpayee changed it.

Vajpayee's plans to link major rivers to solve drought & flood problem & Rs.1 lakh cr 'Sagar Mala' to set new ports were scrapped by UPA :(

It was Vajpayee govt that approved new airports in Bengaluru & Hyderabad (yes, RG). They also approved Mumbai & Delhi airport modernization.

When Vajpayee took power, the wait time for a new LPG connection was 4-5 years. By the time he quit, it was less than 4 DAYS of wait!

India had 3.37 crore gas connections during the first 40 YEARS of LPG system. BJP govt issued 3.92crore new gas connections in just 4 years!

It was Vajpayee and Advani govt that installed the world's largest solar cooking system at Tirupati temple, serving 15,000 meals at a time!

During Vajpayee's rule, every major public sector unit made profit. SAIL, NMDC, BRL, MOIL, Visakhapatnam Steel kind. Most made losses earlier

Turnover of all PSUs of India, increased by a superlative 48% during the first two years of Vajpayee's PMship. Speaks volume about ability!

Turnover of all PSUs of India, increased by a superlative 48% during the first two years of Vajpayee's PMship. Speaks volume about ability!

Vajpayee government planned the revival of all places visited by the great Adi Shankara, Vivekananda and Gandhi. UPA threw it to dustbin :(

Vajpayee and Advani government cared for India's heritage. They introduced India's first ever manuscripts mission to save precious history.

BJP started India's first ever urban slum housing project, Valmiki Ambedkar Aawas Yojna. 2.25 lakh houses & 30000 community toilets planned.

HUDCO loans sanctioned during 1970-1998 (28yrs) was Rs.4,040 cr for urban infrastructure. During BJP rule,Rs.26,000 crores sanctioned in just 6yrs!

It was Vajpayee's BJP government that enacted the mother of all constitutional amendments. Free and Compulsory education to 6-14 age group.

Housing and Urban Dev Corp Limited sanctioned 65 lakh units between 1970 and 1998. BJP govt sanctioned 73 lakh units in just 6 years. #House

The number of Engineering seats in India increased from 1,34,298 to 3,56,268 during Vajpayee's one term. A phenomenal 165% increase!

Most 'secular' media would never highlight. BJP government under Vajpayee & Advani increased Urdu promotional activities by 10 Times!

Vajpayee extended Integrated Child Dev Services (ICDS) to all 5652 blocks of India. Employed 1million Anganwadi workers World's largest in size!

Rahul Gandhi might do stunts, but it was Vajpayee who seriously worked towards Tribal welfare. Setup India's first Tribal Affairs ministry.

For 50 years Gandhi dynasty gave lip service to India's poorer North East. It was Vajpayee's BJP govt that setup a NEW dept for development of NE

  
Twenty to twenty-five years ago, even 10 years ago, few of us had heard of Information Technology. Today, exports from this industry are worth $10 billion — that is, over Rs 45,000 crore a year. That figure is 20 per cent of our total exports.  { Link }


Mananiya Atal Bihari Vajpayee's historical speech during confidence motion in parliament on 27th May 1996 after his 13 days government.

Political energy and expansion made BJP the single-largest political party in the Lok Sabha elected in 1996. Asked to form the government, Shri Vajpayee was sworn in as Prime Minister, but the unfortunately BJP failed to gather enough support from other parties to form a majority. Then Shri Vajpayee resigned after 13 days, when it became clear that it was impossible to gather support of majority.
  
 
What does Congress lead UPA government have to offer as a comparative to the above stated achievements of previous BJP lead NDA government? All those who would like to challenge the stated facts are welcome to place on record facts and figures please do refrain from rhetorical statements and futuristic claims.
 
 “Somehow, this idea makes our policy makers uncomfortable. People in government are much happier when they appear to be “doing things themselves” rather than “letting things happen”. After all, they argue, what is the government for if not to look after the poor? However, the question is what role the government chooses in “looking after” people. A direct-subsidy-oriented approach that seeks to feed “those hungry mouths” is a form of neo-colonialism, which will only seek to cripple our poor and ensure that they remain poor for generations. An intensive rural infrastructure-building approach through their participation can achieve, in some measure, what the food security bill never can to remove poverty.”  Link 

“Since the total subsidy paid by the finance ministry on food was Rs 59,621 crore in 2009-10, and nearly half of it went to the wrong persons, the loss due to corruption is really Rs 28,774 crore – calculated proportionately from the amount of subsidised grain supplied to the PDS system, and the amount that actually went to the intended beneficiaries, according to the National Sample Survey.”  Link
 


Updated on 02nd Jul 2013
The UPA government on Monday admitted before the Supreme Court that the NDA regime, in five years, constructed nearly half the total length of national highways laid during the last 32 years. However, the affidavit revealed that during 1997-2002 (ninth five-year plan), when the NDA was in power, 23,814 km of national highways was added to the existing NH network, or nearly 50% of the total length of national highways constructed in three decades. This remains the largest construction of national highways during any five-year period since independence. 

Updated on 10th Jan 2012

“Language has exhausted itself in describing the year gone by. Every bleak and hopeless analogy has been used: annus horribilis, the year of the scam, the year of the corrupt, the year of nemesis, etc. The ancient Maya civilisation has left for us a blood curdling prophesy, the world will come to an end in December 2012. This may not be true, but the Congress government, submerged in filth, without anyone with inclination, much less courage, to redeem or purify the party is certainly going to end. Anna Hazare may be exhausted or ambivalent, but the people have grasped the truth that their destitution is the direct result of the dacoities perpetrated over the years on their sparse assets.” Link

 
“UPA-1 will be remembered for two things: the nuke deal, and social sector spending — including the farm loan waiver and the National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA). UPA-2 will be remembered for scams, and possibly the Food Security Bill — the NREGA equivalent which is seen as a vote-winner. But, as always, what looks like an achievement seldom remains one when seen from a long-term perspective. The nuke deal has not brought India any closer to energy security. It has only brought us more protests and public angst: at Kudankulam and Jaitapur.” Link



I welcome a debate and discussion on this…As always, please keep your tone civil, your language polite…no sweeping generalisations please and no personal abuse.  Thank you.





Monday, November 21, 2011

The Interview that set a million tongues wagging.


The Interview that set a million tongues wagging.

Media deliberately dividing people: PCI Chief  “Speaking to Karan Thapar, the new Chairman of the Press Council of India Markandey Katju slammed the media saying that he is very disappointed with the way in which the Indian media works. Katju also said that the media is not working for the interest of the people and sometimes divide the people of the country.” 



As is their wont no sooner had the interview of Justice Katju concluded all vantage points were occupied, an incessant chatter of self-righteous indignation and outrage  was unleashed; the irony is that everyone is speaking, but the victims of Media Yes! We are the victims of media for what they publish, broadcast and equally what the media does not publish and broadcast.

In all these years never has the role of the media been scrutinized in detail, is it politically incorrect to inspect the role of the media, or is it a mine field, which deters these so called experts from delving into its role, a potent tool, when employed strategically can inflict immense damage on the victims. Has our media been reporting factually, without bias for one or the other protagonist? 

Plenty has been said yet no cogent case has been made out why Self Regulation should be permitted for electronic media in particular? This central point is missing.

Has the self regulation so far by this section been a roaring success? If yes! Where is the evidence to back the claim? 

What has self regulation yielded to inspire confidence for continuance? Is it their case what transpired in the aftermath of Radia Tapes expose omerta observed by all concerned, and followed by a Court being convened in the studio of a channel where the alleged accused is also the presiding officer, the defendant, who pronounced self to be innocent by way of “Error of Judgment?” Should we be encouraged by the apology of an apology issued by another channel in the wake of 9th Nov 2011 fake live interview! If this is their basis then conversely there is a mountain of evidence in public domain for appointing an Independent Regulator for Media.

Society exists, functions and thrives by a given set of rules and regulation. No component or part is permitted an exception from this. Why should the media then demand that they be exempt from what the rest have to adhere by? 

Can a citizen or a group of citizens demand that they be exempt from IPC & CrPc since they shall setup a self regulation?

Other relevant articles and programs that appeared as a consequence of this interview  

Quick of the blocks is CNN IBN with its Face The Nation on 02nd Nov 2011

FTN: Should Justice Katju apologise to journalists?
 

Not breaking news Namita Bhandare, Hindustan Times  November 11, 2011
“The problem begins when the former Supreme Court judge reaches sweeping conclusions, perhaps oblivious to the fact that many issues that make him queasy (sensationalism, celebrity journalism and paid news) make most journalists queasy too. Perhaps he needs to meet more journalists.” { Link }

When journalists turn brokers By KULDIP NAYAR
“Credibility is like virginity. It either exists or does not. Unfortunately, some top names in Indian journalism have lost their credibility. In the few cases that are in the public domain, they have been found lobbying for the scam-ridden A. Raja. Transcripts of tapped telephone talks by the income-tax department have revealed the manner in which these journalists were throwing their weight around, trying to get the "right" minister from the "right" party. They behaved like powerbrokers and crossed the Lakshmanrekha between legitimate news gathering and lobbying. It is like the fence eating the crop.” { Link }

Justice Markandey Katju clarifies
“By criticizing the media I wanted to persuade the media to change its manner of functioning and not that I wanted to destroy it. The Indian media has a historical role to play in the age of transition, and I wanted to remind the media persons of their historical duty to the nation. Instead of taking my criticism in the correct spirit, a veritable diatribe was launched against me by a section of the media, which painted me as some kind of dictatorial monster.” { Link }

Media self-regulation has failed: Ansari
Mr. Ansari questioned whether such freedoms were being manipulated by media companies for their own purposes. “Can the constitutional safeguards on freedom of speech be used to evade regulation of the commercial persona of media corporates and groups? Where does public interest end and private interest begin?” he asked. “Collective self-regulation has yet to succeed in substantive measure because it is neither universal nor enforceable. Individual self-regulation has also failed due to personal predilection and the prevailing of personal interest over public interest,”  { Link }


‘The media industry needs an independent regulating authority with teeth’
“Control over media is a dangerous proposition, but there needs to be an independent authority which can force corrective action on publishers without interfering with their freedom,” said veteran journalist and former Press Council member Mr Paranjoy Guha Thakurta. His comment summed up the lively interactive panel discussion that followed a screening of the movie ‘Brokering News’ by Moneylife Foundation and vCitizens Action Network and MxM India. 

Control freakery Hindustan Times November 15, 2011 By Arun Jaitley
“The chairman of the Press Council of India, Justice Markandey Katju, lost little time after his appointment to make known his contemptuous views about the Indian media. The obvious danger of talking out of turn in order to sound crusading is that one ceases to be objective. You only have to tabulate the weak points of the target institution and emerge a reformist yourself.” 

Switching off from news By: Vanita Kohli-Khandekar  2011-11-18    Mumbai
“If credibility is the currency a news brand trades in, most are running low these days. And having star anchors will not improve it. It is only when news channels can harness, educate and train young people to gather facts, research and apply rigour to their work will you see good stories on your TV screen. That is when India will see really strong, profitable news broadcasters emerge out the mess the industry has become today.”  { Link }

Who owns media? BY Vaidehi Sachin  afternoonvoice news  Mumbai
“First we have to look that who is running the media. Let us see the ownership of different media agencies.  NDTV: A very popular TV news channel is funded by Gospels of Charity based in Spain and supports communism. Recently, it has developed a soft corner towards Pakistan because the Pakistani President has allowed only this channel to be aired in Pakistan. CNN-IBN: This news channel is 100 per cent funded by the Southern Baptist Church with its branches in all over the world and HQ in US.” { Link }


CHIEF MINISTER ASHOK CHAVAN CLEARS JOURNALISTS HOUSING SCHEME
MHADA will allot a total of 230 flats at Pratiksha Nagar, Sion for journalist members/nominees of the Press Club. This will include 168 High Income Group (HIG) and 62 Middle Income Group (MIG) flats. This will include a reservation of 13 percent for SC applicants and 6 percent for ST applicants.” { Link }


Updated on 25th Nov 2011

Can a reporter make a comment of his own?
The report was illustrated with a photograph. The photograph showed an empty, throne-like chair between one seating Advani and the other seating Modi and the report said: “The reported dissent between Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi and veteran Bharatiya Janata Party leader L.K. Advani… came to the fore… with the two keeping a distance while sharing the dais.”  The report added: “Despite lauding Advani’s fight against corruption, Modi preferred not to take the throne-like seat next to him… throwing enough hints at their continuing cold war”.  It also reported, wrongly, that Modi “sat two chairs away from Advani”. The headline said: “Modi-Advani Cold Vibes Continue”.  { Link }



I welcome a debate and discussion on this…As always, please keep your tone civil, your language polite…no sweeping generalisations please and no personal abuse.  Thank you.






Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Being "Apolitical" is it the best way forward for India?? Friends of BJP event 13th sept 2011 JaiHind College










Brief introduction of the subject (Keynote Address)

"Please don’t politicize the issue is a common refrain to any inconvenient question raised by the protagonists in political sphere and also by the media. This per se instills a sense of revulsion & disgust towards politics & politicians with the other oft repeated Aam Aadmi.

We have been witness to an event the like of which has not been on display previously. Yes protests against corruption. 

The latest addition to our vocabulary is “Apolitical” there have been other words also bandied about like “Unelectable” and “Unelected” which have not found as wide an acceptance or usage by the public in the regular discourse.

We really need to understand this 'Apolitical'. Is it a word, a term, an ideology, an ism, a statement or an expression?

Is this an accessory or a new product? What is its true meaning? Does it have a definite meaning as do other words if it is a word? What are the implications if we do accept this in any of the above forms?

How does this measure up; when we compare with words such ‘Amoral’ & ‘Atheist’? Is Apolitical the opposite of Political and politics or is it devoid of politics.

Do we need this? If yes why?

Does this pit one against the other? Is this an oversimplification or an overkill given the current state of affairs in India!

Would this involve Indians increasing in the political process or will it make Indians more cynical about our political process and hence our democracy. 

There is an urgent need to deconstruct & place this in its true perspective lest we cause any long term damage to our Democracy.

Much harder work is required, more effort than participating in candle vigils or wearing Gandhi caps. Politicians thumping desks and civil society thumping chests don’t make a revolution. Waiting for a hero is not the way. When Andrea lamented to Galileo in Brecht’s play that there were no heroes, Galileo said: pity the nation in need of a hero. And pity, too, the nation that can’t tell apart a real hero from a false one."


Speakers in the chronological order


                
 

  

 


                    Question & Answer Session Video















Tuesday, August 30, 2011

"Have we lost the plot? " "Jaate the Japan pahunch gaye Chin, samajh gaye naa! "







 


  
Heat and dust of Anna’s fast has settled somewhat. Most Indians have been put through a wringer and have experienced a kind of emotional vacuum which can be felt only after an epic event has transpired and sucked out every drop from your body. 

Indians born post Independence specifically second and third generation; had only read or maybe seen it in the fictional form of movies. This was a chance of life time many may find it difficult to come to terms with, what they have witnessed or participated in.

The accompanying euphoria that this event brought with itself is unimaginable. Now is the time to settle down and take stock of what was the genesis, purpose and stated goal of this mass movement called India Against Corruption.

The two most crucial questions that need to be answered! 

1. Was India Against Corruption formed for demanding swift action against the unprecedented corruption of Congress lead UPA government?

 2. Was India Against Corruption formed for Jan Lok Pal bill exclusively?

Have we achieved any of those through the 13 days fast by Anna Hazare? 

There are a host of other questions as well. 

Are all the original members of the team still there? 

What can we project as an immediate achievement? 

Have some original members been ignored totally? 

Has the movement maintained its ‘Apolitical’ character?

Did the team pander to any particular section of the society?

Did the team ignore any section of the society?

Has it focused sharply on the ongoing cases of corruption?

Did this movement divert focus from the urgent issues of corruption?

Have the due credits been placed where ever deserved? 

The list is long and every reader would also have his/her questions to pose and seek answers, hence will not dwell any further on the questions alone.


Let us retrace or as it is said lets start at the very beginning! 

India Against Corruption (IAC), whose website says, “India Against Corruption movement is an expression of collective anger of people of India against corruption.”  

The IAC website lists as founders besides Anna Hazare, Baba Ramdev, Mahamood Madani, Arcbishop Vincent M Concessao, Syed Rizvi, Justice D S Tewatia, B R Lall and others. Where are the other members? Why are they not visible? What is going on? Has this movement been hijacked or converted in to a Jan Lok Pal bill only? 

Have we been lead up the garden path by the so called team Anna?

Without going into the chronology of events and making this into an essay or a dissertation which would make it unbearable or be construed as imposing personal view, shall conclude here with what has been reverberating through length and breath of India Vandemataram Bharat Mata Ki Jai.













 link to Ms.Kiran Bedi's interview Video  with Headlines Today

link to_Arvind Kejriwal's interview goo.gl/64oBS with Headlines Today
 
 

Cartoons on Corruption 















Most Important Update 16th Dec 2013
Internal security and external security is solely predicated on the politics and the prevailing political chemistry of a country. Without security there can be no stability and consequently no development. The security discourse and foreign policy posturing of a country is therefore intrinsic to the politics and cannot be seen through different prisms.     


 Articles on Anna's fast

Anna movement. BJP bracketed with the Congress loses; the Congress does not.



 

“The BJP is certainly deriving some political mileage due to clumsy handling by the government and the Congress."
 

Don’t push for Rahul’s idea’ “Such amendment needs more two-thirds’ support of MPs, which is unlikely,” 

The media and Anna Hazare 

Bipartisanship helped end Annas fast what facilitated an amicable end.The salutary role played by senior BJP leaders.


I welcome a debate and discussion on this…As always, please keep your tone civil, your language polite…no sweeping generalisations please and no personal abuse.  Thank you.